+44 (0)1279 600 440
Environmental Innovations
Environmental Innovations
  • Home
  • About
  • Products & Services
    • Overviews
      • Spill, Firewater, CSO and In-Drain Containment
      • Flood and Blocked Sewer detection, and mitigation solutions
      • Complete Interceptor and Separator Systems, from tank to monitoring
      • Wireless and Remote links, sensors and alarms
    • Solutions
      • The Flapstopper
      • The Drainstopper
      • The Telestopper
      • Flood Warning Systems and Alarm
      • Blocked Sewer Detection
      • Vertical Stack Block Sewer Detection
      • Interceptor Alarms
      • Basic Oil Interceptor Alarm
      • Fully Integrated Oil Interceptor Alarm
      • Bypass Interceptor
      • Full Retention Oil Interceptor
      • Drainage and CCTV Surveys
    • Wireless
      • Wireless Call Point
      • Wireless and Remote links, sensors and alarms
      • Industrial Kitchen Blocked Sewer Sentinel
      • Wireless Link Transmitter
  • Servicing & Installation
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu back  

Containment News February 2016: ‘Pollution Fines Increase’

February 19, 2016UncategorizedBy enviro

Pollution Fines Increase

The full edition of February’s containment news is available here with all of the news, stories, and live links: *Containment News February 2016 PDF Version*

‘Pollution Fines Increase’

There has been a very significant increase recently in the size of fines being handed out in England to water companies for sewage pollution incidents.  Thames Water was hit with a record breaking £1million fine in January after toxic sewage waste leaked into the Grand Union Canal in Buckinghamshire over a nine-month period between July 2012 and April 2013. In his summing up, the sentencing judge said that  “the time has now come for the courts to make clear that very large organisations such as [Thames Water] really must bring about the reforms and improvements for which they say they are striving because if they do not the sentences passed upon them for environmental offences will be sufficiently severe to have a significant impact on their finances.”  In the same month Yorkshire Water was slapped with a £600,000 fine for a sewage leak which killed 860 fish in a nature park in Wakefield.

To put the size of these fines in context, compare them with the fines handed down to companies and individuals in the last financial year by cases brought to court by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA): they totalled £284,400 and that was a record, the highest combined amount in the last 5 years.  In previous years average fines for UK utility companies have tended to be between £5,000 and £10,000, and it’s very rare to see a fine higher than £500 for pollution prosecutions in Northern Ireland.

Unless the punishment fits the crime and is proportionally related to the offenders’ wealth there is a  reprehensible opportunity to take gambles with the cost of rectifying potential problems against the projected cost of an incident.  An extreme infamous example was uncovered in the car industry, where it was found that the cost of recalling and fixing a known mechanical problem was weighed against a projection of the estimated cost of lawsuits from accidents caused by the defect.

This long overdue, and hopefully sustained change in the severity of fines should be prompting a less miserly approach by the water companies to putting their infrastructure in order.  To coincide with this apparently tougher stance on pollution fines it would make perfect sense to reform the ridiculous practice of only monitoring coastal pollution between May and September.  The very existence of a bathing water “season” implies that by definition, there are 7 months of the year when polluting the sea with untreated sewage is not really such a problem. This assumption is further strengthened by the recent de-designation of a polluted Yorkshire beach as ‘bathing water’ because a controversial survey indicated “low user numbers” (2,484 going in the sea for a paddle and a further 276 swimming).  A recent study concluded that “most rivers, lakes, coastal and ground waters in England will still not meet legally binding EU water pollution targets by 2021”.

It’s worth remembering that pollution incidents are not confined to calculated negligence, carelessness, or bad H&S procedures, they can be triggered by fire, mechanical failure, vandalism or acts of terrorism via explosives or cyber attack.

Hopefully the media coverage of these fines will make companies of all sizes review their vulnerabilities and instigate the ‘stitch in time saves nine’ principle, and at the same time employ due diligence with regard to their environmental insurance cover.  A company’s spill and firewater incident contingency plans should be as important an element of it’s annual review as it’s projected sales figures.  A polluting company’s reputation can take even longer to recover than the natural environment they have contaminated.

Phil Bremner

Editor:  Containment News, Flood News, Wireless eNews & LPRA eNews  CONTACT

Containment News January 2016

Containment News February 2016 PDF Version

environment agencyEnvironmental liability directivepollution finespollution prevention guidelinessewage incidentSurfers Against Sewagethames waterwater pollution
About the author

enviro

Related posts
Pollution Containment Device
Box Valve Automated PCD Installed at the UK’s First EV Battery Recycling Plant
February 11, 2021
Bonfire of Environmental Regulations
Containment News July 2016: ‘Bonfire of Environmental Legislation’
July 23, 2016
Brexit Environmental Impacts
Containment News June 2016: ‘Environmental Impacts of Brexit’
June 16, 2016
Pollution Conspiracy Theory Alert
Containment News May 2016: ‘Conspiracy Theory Alert’
May 12, 2016
Surfers against sewage, sewage free seas 2016
Containment News April 2016: ‘Sewage Free Seas’
April 15, 2016
Lacklustre direction for environmental targets
Containment News March 2016: ‘Lacklustre Direction for Environmental Targets’
March 21, 2016
WHAT CLIENTS SAY
  • “Containment news is a great free resource, packed with the latest relevant news on environmental crimes, actions and solutions.  Subscribe now and ensure you are kept up to date with all the important environmental issues.”

    Andy Cummins – Campaign Director for Surfers Against Sewage
  • “Containment News is an informative news-feed and I’d encourage all of our Environment Officers to sign-up to it.”

     

    Paul Linster – CEO of the Environment Agency
CONTACT US
The Innovation Farm
Sawbridgeworth Road
Little hallingbury
Bishop’s Stortford
Hertfordshire
CM22 7QU
QUICK LINKS
  • Case Studies
  • FAQ's
  • Contact
  • Brochure Download
  • Environmental Regulations
CONTAINMENT NEWS
  • Box Valve Automated PCD Installed at the UK’s First EV Battery Recycling Plant
    February 11, 2021
  • Bonfire of Environmental Regulations
    Containment News July 2016: ‘Bonfire of Environmental Legislation’
    July 23, 2016
  • Brexit Environmental Impacts
    Containment News June 2016: ‘Environmental Impacts of Brexit’
    June 16, 2016
© 2015 Environmental Innovations Ltd

Website by Brilliant Ltd